Advent Day 12: 1997 Isle Of Jura 17 y.o. (Samaroli)

Secret Spirits Advent Calendar Day 12 – December 12th026

1997 Isle Of Jura 17 y.o. (Samaroli)

Cask #9118

43% abv

Score:  86.5/100
A whisky from the Secret Spirits Advent Calendar First Edition. 


Now here’s a bit of a fun one.

It’s a rare occasion I come across independently bottled single cask releases of Jura.  There was a rather spectacular Douglas Laing 25 y.o. I tried on Islay a couple years back.  And I think maybe an SMWS release or two, but not many other Indie Juras make it our way.  Surprising, really, when one considers the volume the distillery produces (a couple million litres per annum), and how much ends up blended away.  You’d think more casks would wind up in the hands of private enterprise.

Leaving that aside, what we find in this particular Hebridean malt is a character quite apart from what I normally find in Jura.  I suppose if you really concentrate, you’ll pick up on some of the familial lineage, but the hallmarks that normally announce this whisky loud and clear are instead here a mere whisper.  And that is saying something, as I find Jura, as a rule, to have a very pronounced and singular profile.  The salinity throughout and a touch of nuttiness on the palate are the only hints at which distillery this really is.  If tasted blind, I may have guessed.  But then again…I may not have.

Further…it’s nice to see Jura mature and pure.  Older than most of their releases and dressed in none of the wine cask adornment they seem so fond of.  Lest you think I’m slagging Jura here, think again.  I have a real soft spot for this distillery, and am probably somewhat over-forgiving, if anything.  I like their malts and…if I’m being honest…their entire raison d’être.

I’ve said it before, and likely will again…these unpredictable l’il beauts are what make whisky fun.  They keep us (or me, at least) on our toes and allow every bottle purchased to hold a little bit of anticipation.

Nose:  NEVER would I peg this as a Jura.  Roman nougat.  Cookie dough.  Soft white cake.  Marzipan.  A slight saline edge too, almost like Play Dough.  Some ginger and pepper.  A wee splash of OJ.  Just the vaguest hint of smoke.  Kinda putty-ish.  A very ‘dull’ nose…and I don’t mean that in a bad way, believe it or not.  Just no sharp edges.  Simple, soft and pleasant home-y notes.  Very pleasant.

Palate:  More of that almond note and still getting the white gooey Roman Nougat flavours.  Salt water taffee.  Dried orange fruit.  Hint of peach.  Finally some of those Jura walnutty/chestnut notes I expected.

Thoughts:  Very atypical of Jura.  Very cool.  If the nose had been a little more aligned with the palate we’d have scored higher.

Bonus:  My mate, Jonathan, and I are gonna blog on these drams side by side through the season.  Here’s a link to his notes on the same whisky at


– Reviewed by:  Curt

– Photo:  Curt

3 thoughts on “Advent Day 12: 1997 Isle Of Jura 17 y.o. (Samaroli)

  1. Devin

    Curt any thoughts on the later batches of the 16 year old distillery bottling?

    I’m tasting for the first time tonight, and felt much the same way you did with this one as far as overall feel and quality . Even the dull but not off-putting nose. Sweet over ripe fruits on the nose with soft spice, Wood, nuts, and pine pitch with citrus on delivery and to the end. Like you said about your sample, simple, soft and homey…

    Different notes, and incomparable given the vatting vs single cask, but I was surprised by the fact that from start to finish there was not one bad taste I got from this one. I’m sure that without chill filtering this would be a knock out!

    1. ATW Post author

      This is a prime example of what makes indies so much fun. Thanks for sharing your notes.

      No, I’ve not tried the new 16. Apparently it’s Wee Willie Tait’s favorite of the range, but I’ve not had their 16 OB in a few years now. Not sure if there has been much variation. If you pick one up, lemme know what you think.



  2. Devin

    Yea I’ve had the bottle sitting for a few months now and cracked it the other night..

    Personally I was let down by the prophecy, and the 10 and 12 year old’s, but just happen to love the later versions of superstition (As an everyday dram and for what it is). But as mentioned I was happy to find not one off note from start to finish in this 16. Nothing bitter, nothing blemished. I finished the glass feeling the same about it as I did with say, the Macallan Sienna…Could there have been more to it? Sure…but what was there was very good and somehow the dullness didn’t come off as a let down.

    Anyway the similarities between what I got from the 16 and what you wrote here about the Samaroli sample made me put my 2 cents in on it, cheers!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s